Clubcard In-store Trials
Overview
Clubcard was in decline (Joins, Swipes, Spends). Building on our online success, we were tasked with applying insights & design holistically to identify opportunities to improve engagement.
I worked with a research and product manager to focus on in-store experiences and better understand the gaps in our customers' shopping journey.
Stakeholder Interviews, In-store observations, Diary Studies, Insight Analysis, Ideation Sessions, Storyboarding and Prototyping enabled:
Rapid test-and-learn activities in stores that led to regional trials of our ideas. I fed insights back to leadership and the product team backlog.
Opportunity Mapping
Mapping Clubcard touchpoints with In-Store Shopping Missions
In-store Observations & Interviews
There are many was Clubcard could feature more promenantly in stores for customers.
Diary Studies & In-Home Interviews
I partnered with a researcher to conduct diary studies with 20 customers covering the 5 Tesco Personas in locations in the North & South of England.
We chose diary studies to gain a holistic view of the customer experience and to access situations where our presence would otherwise have interfered with the results. We also wanted to understand what ‘getting rewarded’ means to our customers and identify opportunities to make Tesco Clubcard relevant and engaging.
We then visited our participants in their homes for follow-up In-home Interviews.
Processing Insights...
“Clubcard doesn’t pass the elevator pitch test.”
“My dad is a Clubcard Jedi!”
“It’s nice to get something back from shopping I have to do anyway.”
“If you don’t use it, you lose it.”
“Tesco Clubcard helps me to do the things I might not be able to afford.”
“Teach me digital things so I can keep up with grandkids; I would love that”
“I like to save up for a treat with my girlfriends.”
“Don’t lock me into anything; I like independence and use to get my way”
Persona Analysis
New Clubcard customer profiles emerged that seemed to deviate from the Tesco Families.
Focus shifted to Customer awareness and engagement with Clubcard.
Tesco Families
(Existing Persona)
Tesco Bank
(Existing Persona)
Clubcard
(New Personas)
In-store observations and interviews
Clubcard moments in-store that might appeal to The Mayers.
Ways to enjoy Clubcard Rewards as a family
Emphasising the Clubcard value of using Tesco Services
In-store observations and interviews
Clubcard moments in-store that might appeal to Roshni
Highlighting the value of collecting points on small spends
Instant Join / Rewards
Ideation for our design profiles
Storyboarding for our design profiles
Prioritisation & Workshops
Opportunities were prioritised for in-store trials in a series of workshops based on:
Structuring ideas & forming hypothesis
Clubcard Stickers
Customers were collecting fewer points. We learned that customers don’t always have their card on them for several reasons.
We proposed a sticker concept as an alternative to give customers more flexibility to earn Clubcard points.
Designing the sticker and mailer required cross-business collaboration, along with in-store guerrilla testing and Remote Testing in preparation for a Trial in Maidstone covering 9 stores and 38,000 customers.
1 in 5 had them. Customers placed the sticker on a variety of belongings: Wallet, Phone, Phone cover, Purse, car key ring. Some concerns, but mainly learnings, were operational, relating to staff training, targeting & Clubcard retention.
Why stickers?
We learnt that customers don’t always have their card because:
Popped out for lunch only with their payment card or phone
Their fob is a different set of keys.
They don’t see the value in it taking up ‘valuable’ space in their wallet.
They weren’t expecting to visit the store that day.
They forgot their card, or it's lost or damaged.
Therefore, we proposed the sticker concept as an alternative to provide more flexibility for earning Clubcard points.
Reactions to concept:
From in-store interviews and guerrilla testing, we learned:
Customers needed some guidance about where to place their stickers.
Some had concerns about the sticker's quality.
Some thought the sticker was contactless.
Not all understood the benefit of using Clubcard.
From the remote study we learned:
50/50 would want to receive the sticker by post or in-store
85% found the concept and mailer content easy to understand
80% thought 3 stickers would suffice
1 in 3 can be expected to use the stickers. The main driver is convenience (always there, less effort, less space).
7 in 10 would complete the mail-in survey.
1 in 5 would do nothing if the sticker stopped working.
Clubcard Stickers Trial
The Clubcard Smart Stickers trial ran for 8 weeks in January in the Maidstone area, covering 9 stores. 38,232 customers received their stickers in the post.
What worked:
1 in 5 had them. Customers placed the sticker on a variety of belongings: Wallet, Phone, Phone cover, Purse, car key ring.
“Only received them yesterday - but already used them”
“I stuck it on my Nectar card to save some space”
“It’s really useful because when I get my car washed, I have
to give them my keys, which have my Clubcard on them”
“A good idea to save me clearing my handbag looking for my
‘real’ card”
“I’m always forgetting to take my Clubcard with me when visiting.
Tesco. I used them the day after I received them. Checkout assistant
Unfamiliar with Stickers, but it worked a charm.”
What didn't:
Training needs to be more effective for call centre and in-store colleagues.
Retention & acquisition journeys need to be explored.
Re-trial required. No impact on penetration due to targeting errors.
Not relevant for Tesco Credit Card customers.
Always have their Clubcard on them, so this isn’t relevant to them (tend to be the Carol or Dawns)
They don’t want to stick anything on their belongings.
Clubcard Stickers Design Process
As Design Lead, I worked directly with a Product Manager and Research Manager, collaborating with several departments to ensure the product was practical and successful.
Identify & understand the customer problem we’re trying to solve.
Clubcard swipes are declining.
Gather customer insight.
Store visits, interviews & observations.
Plan & prep customer diary studies.
Conduct in-home interviews.
Process insight
Create affinity diagrams.
Inform persona creation.
Identify opportunities (the Sticker is born).
Concept Design
Identify Customer Journey(s) for design and testing requirements.
Iterate Sticker designs (Size, shape and layout).
Iterate mailer designs (Content, format and layout)
Iterate website designs (Content and layout)
Test Concept
Inform the test plan and preparations.
Test iterations in stores with customers.
Inform and prepare remote testing of the mailer with 500 customers across 5 segments.
Refine
Translate testing analysis into final designs.
Co-ordinate with product manager to ensure that the concept is finalised and operational.
Trial
8 weeks, Maidstone, covering 9 stores and 38,000 customers.
Analysis & Refinements (Included in previous pages)
Launch Nationwide (Parked due to dependencies and org changes)
Clubcard - Points equal prizes
Clubcard swipes were declining, especially in small-store formats. Customers did not see the value in collecting Clubcard Points on small spends.
The progress bar concept aimed to remind customers that every (‘little helps’) shop contributes to a reward they might be interested in. A way to utilise customer data to emphasise that Points = Prizes
I explored progress bar solutions via rapid prototyping and test-and-learn activities in stores with stakeholders.
Problem:
Clubcard swipes were declining, especially in small-store formats. Customers don't see the value in collecting Clubcard Points on small spends (e.g., buying lunch or a top-up shop on the way home).
Action:
The progress bar concept aimed to remind customers that every (little helps) shop goes toward a reward they care about.
Utilise customer data to emphasise that Points = Prizes
Outcome:
Need to explore the trigger to set a goal.
Problems with proposition.
On-boarding may or may not be required.
Explore other applications
However, we parked the opportunity due to technology capacity and priorities.
Clubcard Progress Bar (Design & Insights)
Clubcard Progress Bar (Online Applications)
Clubcard - Rewards In-Store
Awareness of the loyalty scheme is low. The majority of customers are in-store and the best rewards are online. Only 22% of our members have participated. The Online process is complicated & additional work to their shopping trip.
There’s a big opportunity to increase engagement in the scheme by making rewards more accessible in stores.
Instant code-packs were proposed and explored in stores to give customers a way to discover the range of rewards available and access them instantly.
Although there was an enthusiastic response, the activity surfaced many operational and customer dependencies with bringing rewards in stores (Clubcard status, requires explanation, till services, permanent store presence)
Problem:
Only 50% are aware you can use your vouchers with Partners.
Only 22% of our members have participated.
Customers not engaged with the scheme (80%) only think about Clubcard when in-store.
The Online process is complicated & additional work to their shopping trip.
Insight:
From our diary studies and surveys, we learned:
Customers actively decide not to swipe. The hassle of swiping a card outweighs the perceived value of the ‘reward’ benefit.
Customers do not clearly understand the benefits of joining (e.g. what does Clubcard get me?)
Customer awareness of partners (and therefore potential incentive to join/swipe) is low, especially in small stores.
Customers don’t know how to redeem with partners.
Reactions to Concept:
From in-store interviews and guerrilla testing, we learned:
The concept increased awareness of Clubcard Rewards.
Customers liked that it was simple, instant, and a more convenient way to gift Clubcard Rewards.
The Board/Wall wasn’t noticed and needed to be pointed out.
Customers might not interact with the product on first encounter. It may get noticed over time.
More work is needed to define the in-store experience.
The value and instructions need to be clearer.
We need to distinguish it from Gift Cards.
Clubcard Progress Bar (Online Applications)
Currently , there is no method for customers to spend their Clubcard value on partners in-store.
For Clubcard Boost Partners; customers are required to go to a website and complete an additional transaction.
Lets make it less work and more accessible to our in-store shoppers by enabling customers to discover and purchase Boost Partners in-store in a way that fits in with their natural Tesco shopping behaviour.
Rewards In-store (Iteration)
Rewards In-store (Relevance)
Most members will spend in-store (60%) or not at all (20%).
Design & refine the solution (Method, Location, Customer type, Exchange).
Not a standalone solution... issues occur with scalability & timelines.