< UX Design Case Studies

Product Availability

Overview

90% of online sales were store collections. However, stores had limited storage.

As a result, Customers struggled to find products in their chosen locations.

I iterated on solutions with guerrilla and A/B testing to surface product availability in search results & listings.

This led to a 14% decrease in product views and a 1.4% to 3% increase in conversion.

Problem:

Customers struggled to find products in their chosen/preferred location because store availability was unreliable.

Customers yo-yoed between product listings and product pages to find out whether the item(s) they wanted (or alternatives) were in stock.

On average, customers would yo-yo 9 times, with 26% switching store locations to check availability in other stores.

For our customers, this felt like the "postcode lottery". We had the perception of being the "out-of-stock company"

Appetite Test

I hypothesised that surfacing store availability on product listings would help customers find products (or alternatives) more easily.

Focus of test

  • Reduce yoyo-ing (page views)

  • Surface Availability to help fulfil need in chosen location more easily (conversion)

  • Probing for impact on conversion mix

    • Pay online, Delivery... 10%

    • Pay online- Collection... 20% (85% Collect)

    • Pay in-store, Reservation... 70% (60% Collect)

  • Concerns with impact on demand forecasting

  • Concerns with impact on delivery

  • Concerns with impact on stock movements

A/B Test Results

  • 20% interact, 60% click yes (use saved store)

  • 6% change store, convert 30% better

  • 4% fewer product page views

  • 9% decrease in delivery

  • 0.2% Increase in conversion

  • No Impact on multi-variant products

  • No Impact on fulfilment mix

  • Not helpful when no alternatives

Second Test

Adjustments

  • Go bolder to encourage interaction.

  • Include Delivery to address the previous test's negative impact.

  • Auto-on. Default to stored addresses

  • A/B Test Results

  • 10% fewer product page views

  • 0.8% Increase in conversion

  • 3% decrease in Delivery

Next Steps

  • There seems to be demand for the feature. It reduces Yoyo-ing and provides transparency for customers.

  • Collection Conversion Uplift may grow over time as customers become familiar with the feature.

  • Surface Delivery at the same time to further address impact on Delivery and to remove hidden opportunities for customers.

Final Release

Results

  • 14% fewer product page views

  • Collection Conversion up 1.4%

  • Conversion of delivery-only items up 3%

  • (worth 7 million to the business)

  • Positive impact on conversion

  • Positive impact on fulfilment mix

  • No impact on stock movements

  • Positive impact on delivery

  • Unknown impact on demand forecasting

Conclusion

  • Improved conversion

  • Improved App performance

  • Which are both good for the customer!

Questions for further discovery

  • Experience doesn’t address the root cause of items being out of stock.

  • Not helpful if a specific item isn’t in stock

  • Not helpful if there are no alternatives in stock

  • Availability isn’t perhaps considered by the customer during browsing (Especially when not purchasing in the same session)

Under the hood

Examples of what was involved

Planning

Applying stock movements to listings...

Iteration

Iterating suitable interactions...

Delivery

Scaling out for development...